Columbus Settles Civil Rights Case for 2015 Shooting of James England
“When Keith Abel shot me, it changed my life forever. I was cooperating and doing what I was told and he pulled the trigger anyway, for no reason.”
Background
On February 6, 2015, during what should have been a routine arrest, Columbus police officer Keith Abel shot James England twice in an inexcusable use of force. Despite England’s compliance with the officers' commands, the situation escalated when Abel and three other officers attempted to pull England through a chest-height opening from an enclosed porch. England, who was handcuffed, felt the officers begin to lift him when he was suddenly pushed forward and shot twice.
CPD’s Keith Abel, who pulled the trigger, was found by a supervising lieutenant, commander, and deputy chief in the chain-of-command review of the shooting to have violated CPD policies. The CPD’s Firearms Review Board agreed. However, then-Chief Kimberley Jacobs deemed Abel’s actions as within policy, controversially choosing not to discipline him. This decision was met with public outcry and led to a prolonged legal battle spearheaded by England to seek justice for the unwarranted violence he endured.
Approach & Resolution
Our team took on England's case with a commitment to challenge the misuse of power and hold the Columbus Police Department accountable. Despite the City of Columbus and Officer Abel's attempts to dismiss the lawsuit and claim qualified immunity, FG+G persistently fought through the legal obstacles.
Facing the imminent trial and the potential for public exposure of CPD’s egregious handling of the situation, the City agreed to a settlement of $300,000. This settlement not only represents a victory for England but also underscores the necessity for accountability and transparency within the Columbus Police Department. We continue to pursue justice for other victims of CPD misconduct and protect our community members from excessive police force.